Is it legal to download videos? A clear answer by situation and country
Key takeaways
- Downloading a video is legal when you own it, when its licence allows it (public domain, Creative Commons), when the rights holder gives permission, or when a legal exception covers your use.
- In the European Union, the private copy exception of Directive 2001/29/EC only covers copies made from a lawful source, as the Court of Justice ruled in ACI Adam (C-435/12, 10 April 2014).
- The United States has no general private copy right: personal downloading of copyrighted video is judged under fair use, 17 U.S.C. 107, case by case.
- Circumventing DRM is prohibited separately, by 17 U.S.C. 1201 in the US and by Article 6 of Directive 2001/29/EC in the EU, even when the underlying use might be lawful.
- Platform terms of service are a contract: breaking them is not a crime in itself, but can lead to account suspension or civil claims.

Downloading a video is legal when you have a right to the copy: you made the video, its licence allows copying, the rights holder agreed, or a legal exception applies to your situation. Outside those cases, saving a protected video without permission is copyright infringement in most countries, even for private viewing. Breaking DRM is a separate offence, and platform terms add a contractual layer on top.
This page is general information, not legal advice. Laws differ between countries and change over time. For a specific case, ask a qualified lawyer.
The four situations where downloading is clearly lawful
- It is your own content. Your talk, your stream, your meeting recording. You hold the copyright (or your employer does), so you can keep copies. See how to back up your own YouTube channel or archive your livestreams.
- The video is in the public domain. US federal government works, old films whose copyright expired, works dedicated with CC0. Our public-domain film checklist shows how to verify.
- The licence allows it. Creative Commons licences all permit copying and redistribution, with conditions such as attribution. Read Creative Commons video licences explained.
- The rights holder gave permission, either explicitly or through a download button provided by the service.
Everything else falls into the grey zone of exceptions, which vary by country.
United States: fair use, not a private copy right
US law does not contain a general “personal copy” exception. Personal downloading is assessed under fair use, defined in 17 U.S.C. 107. Courts weigh four factors:
| Factor | Question the court asks |
|---|---|
| Purpose and character | Is the use commercial or non-profit, transformative or a plain copy? |
| Nature of the work | Is it factual or highly creative, published or unpublished? |
| Amount used | How much of the work was copied? |
| Market effect | Does the copy replace a sale, rental or licence? |
The best-known precedent is Sony Corp. of America v. Universal City Studios (1984), where the Supreme Court held that recording free broadcast TV to watch later (“time-shifting”) was fair use. Copying an entire film that is sold or rented online usually fails the market-effect factor. The Copyright Office Fair Use Index summarises hundreds of decisions if you want to compare with your case.
European Union: a private copy exception limited to lawful sources
Article 5(2)(b) of Directive 2001/29/EC allows member states to permit reproductions “by a natural person for private use and for ends that are neither directly nor indirectly commercial”, on condition that rights holders receive fair compensation, usually through a levy on storage media.
In ACI Adam (C-435/12, 10 April 2014), the Court of Justice ruled that this exception does not cover copies made from an unlawful source. Downloading a pirated copy is therefore not “private copying”, wherever you live in the EU. Our page on the private copy exception covers the details, including the French version of the rule.
United Kingdom: no private copy exception in force
The UK introduced a narrow personal-copy exception (section 28B of the Copyright, Designs and Patents Act 1988) in October 2014. The High Court quashed it in 2015 (R (BASCA) v Secretary of State, [2015] EWHC 1723 and 2041 (Admin)) because it provided no compensation for rights holders. What remains is narrower, notably the time-shifting exception for broadcasts in section 70 CDPA, which allows recording a broadcast in domestic premises to watch it at a more convenient time.
France: copie privée, from a lawful source only
Article L.122-5, 2° of the Code de la propriété intellectuelle allows copies “strictly reserved for the private use of the copyist”, made from a lawful source. The levy that compensates authors is set by Article L.311-1 and the following articles. Sharing files on peer-to-peer networks is monitored by Arcom, which runs the graduated response procedure inherited from Hadopi.
Germany and Canada: two other models
- Germany. Section 53 of the Copyright Act (UrhG) allows single copies for private use, but not from a source that was “obviously unlawfully produced or made publicly available”. Section 54 makes manufacturers of devices and storage media pay a remuneration that compensates those copies.
- Canada. Section 29.22 of the Copyright Act lets an individual reproduce a work for private purposes only if the source copy is not infringing and was legally obtained (not borrowed or rented), no technological protection measure is circumvented, the reproduction is not given away and it is used only privately. Section 29.23 separately allows recording a broadcast to watch it later.
Country comparison at a glance
| Country | Personal copy rule | Source must be lawful? | Breaking DRM | Compensation |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| United States | Fair use (17 U.S.C. 107), case by case | Weighs heavily in practice | Prohibited (s. 1201), limited exemptions | None for video |
| United Kingdom | No general exception since 2015; time-shifting (s. 70) | n/a | Prohibited | None |
| France | Copie privée (L.122-5, 2° CPI) | Yes, written in the law since 2011 | Offence (L.335-3-1) | Levy on media |
| Germany | Privatkopie (§ 53 UrhG) | Yes, not obviously unlawful | Prohibited (§ 95a UrhG) | Levy (§ 54 UrhG) |
| Canada | Private purposes (s. 29.22) | Yes, legally obtained, not borrowed | Excluded by s. 29.22(1)(c) | Levy on audio media only |
| EU baseline | Optional exception, art. 5(2)(b) | Yes, ACI Adam (2014) | Prohibited, art. 6 | Required |
Concrete scenarios: can I download this?
| Scenario | Short answer | Why |
|---|---|---|
| A NASA launch video | Generally yes | NASA material is generally not subject to US copyright; check the item notes for third-party content |
| A Wikimedia Commons clip | Yes | Every file carries a free licence or public-domain status; credit the author when required |
| A lecture released under CC BY-NC-SA | Yes, for non-commercial use | The licence allows copying with attribution |
| Your company’s all-hands recording | Ask your employer | The rights usually belong to the organisation |
| A music video on a streaming platform | Usually no | Protected work, platform terms forbid it, often DRM |
| A news clip you need as evidence | Possibly | Preservation and reporting exceptions vary; see OSINT video preservation |
| A film on a subscription service | No outside the app | Encrypted with DRM; use the official offline mode |
DRM: a separate prohibition
Even when a use is lawful, breaking a technical protection measure is a distinct violation:
- United States: 17 U.S.C. 1201 prohibits circumventing access controls and trafficking in circumvention tools. The Copyright Office grants limited exemptions every three years (for example for some educational and accessibility uses).
- European Union: Article 6 of Directive 2001/29/EC requires member states to protect “effective technological measures”. France implements it in Articles L.331-5 and L.335-3-1 of its intellectual property code.
That is why reputable tools refuse DRM-protected streams. Our DRM explainer describes what Widevine, FairPlay and PlayReady actually do.
Platform terms: a contract, not a criminal law
Most platforms forbid downloading in their terms. YouTube’s Terms of Service, for example, prohibit downloading content unless the service provides a download option or you have prior written permission from YouTube and the rights holders. Breaching terms is a contractual matter: the usual consequence is account suspension, not prosecution. It still matters for professional users, whose organisation may be held to those terms.
A quick decision table
| Situation | Usually lawful? |
|---|---|
| Your own upload, stream or meeting | Yes |
| Public-domain or CC0 video | Yes |
| CC BY / CC BY-SA video, with attribution | Yes |
| Offline copy through the platform’s own download button | Yes, within the app’s limits |
| Personal copy of a protected video from a lawful source, EU | Depends on national private copy rules |
| Personal copy of a protected video, US | Fair-use analysis, often weak |
| Copy from a pirate site | No |
| Copy that requires breaking DRM | No |
| Re-uploading someone else’s video | No, unless licensed |
Safe habits
- Keep a note of the source and licence for each file you download, ideally in the file name or metadata.
- Prefer official open-data archives such as the Internet Archive or the NASA library when you need reusable footage.
- Avoid ad-heavy converter websites: beyond the legal question, they carry real security risks.
Frequently asked questions
Is it illegal to download a YouTube video?
It depends on the video and your country. Downloading your own uploads or openly licensed videos is lawful. YouTube's terms forbid downloading other content unless the service offers a download option or you have written permission, so even a copyright-lawful download can breach the platform contract.
Can I go to jail for downloading a video?
Criminal copyright cases target commercial-scale infringement and distribution, not a single personal download. Private downloads of protected works without permission are normally a civil matter, which can still mean damages. Circumventing DRM can carry criminal penalties in some countries, including France and the United States.
Is downloading a video for personal use fair use?
Not automatically. Fair use under 17 U.S.C. 107 weighs four factors: purpose, nature of the work, amount used and effect on the market. Copying a whole film you could rent usually weighs against fair use; time-shifting broadcast TV was accepted by the Supreme Court in Sony v. Universal (1984).
Is it legal to download a video if it is freely available online?
Free to watch does not mean free to copy. A video streamed for free is still protected by copyright. What matters is the licence: public domain or Creative Commons videos may be downloaded; ordinary uploads need permission or a legal exception.
Does using an open-source tool like yt-dlp make a download legal?
No. The tool is lawful, but legality depends on what you download and how. yt-dlp is widely used for legitimate archiving, research and backups of your own content, which is what this site documents.
Sources and open data
- 17 U.S. Code 107, Limitations on exclusive rights: Fair use · Legal Information Institute, Cornell Law School
- 17 U.S. Code 1201, Circumvention of copyright protection systems · Legal Information Institute, Cornell Law School
- U.S. Copyright Office Fair Use Index · U.S. Copyright Office
- Directive 2001/29/EC on the harmonisation of certain aspects of copyright (InfoSoc Directive) · EUR-Lex
- Judgment in Case C-435/12, ACI Adam and Others · Court of Justice of the European Union
- Copyright, Designs and Patents Act 1988 · legislation.gov.uk
- Code de la propriété intellectuelle (France) · Légifrance
- YouTube Terms of Service · YouTube
Related guides
- Private copy exception
What the EU private copy exception allows for video, the lawful-source rule from ACI Adam, levies on devices, DRM limits and the UK situation.
- Creative Commons for video
The six Creative Commons licences, CC0 and the Public Domain Mark applied to video: what you may download, edit and publish, and how to credit correctly.
- Downloader site risks
The real risks of online video converter sites: malvertising, fake download buttons, notification spam, bundled installers, and how to verify a tool.
- DRM and Widevine
What DRM is, how Widevine, PlayReady and FairPlay protect streams, why bypassing them is illegal in the US, EU and France, and the legal ways to watch offline.
- Back up your channel
Back up every video you uploaded: Google Takeout for bulk export, YouTube Studio downloads, metadata, Brand Account pitfalls and a 3-2-1 storage plan.