CH05 / Law & safety

The private copy exception: what it really allows for video

Last updated Editorial team Video Downloader Info8 segments~5 min

Key takeaways

  1. The private copy exception lets a natural person copy a work for private, non-commercial use without asking permission, where national law provides it.
  2. It comes from Article 5(2)(b) of Directive 2001/29/EC, which makes it optional for member states and conditional on fair compensation for rights holders.
  3. Since the ACI Adam judgment (C-435/12, 10 April 2014), copies made from an unlawful source are excluded everywhere in the EU.
  4. Rights holders are compensated through levies on blank media and devices, such as hard drives, memory cards and smartphones.
  5. The exception does not authorise breaking DRM, sharing the copy, or uploading it anywhere.
A VHS videocassette, the format behind the first private copy debates
Image: VHS videocassette - front,LoMit,CC BY-SA 4.0,via Wikimedia Commons.

The private copy exception allows a person to copy a work for their own private, non-commercial use without asking the rights holder, in the countries that provide it and only within strict limits. For video, the three limits that matter are: the source must be lawful, the copy must stay private, and no DRM may be circumvented. Rights holders are compensated through a levy on storage devices.

General information only, not legal advice. National implementations differ; check your country’s law or ask a lawyer for a specific case.

Where does the exception come from?

The legal basis is Article 5(2)(b) of Directive 2001/29/EC (the InfoSoc Directive). It allows member states to provide an exception for reproductions “on any medium made by a natural person for private use and for ends that are neither directly nor indirectly commercial, on condition that the rightholders receive fair compensation”.

Two features follow from that wording:

  • it is optional: each country chooses whether and how to implement it;
  • it is paid for: there must be fair compensation, which is why levies exist.

The lawful-source rule: ACI Adam (C-435/12)

Before 2014, some countries tolerated private copies from any source. In ACI Adam and Others (C-435/12, judgment of 10 April 2014), the Court of Justice of the EU ruled that national law may not allow private copies made from an unlawful source. Tolerating them would encourage the circulation of pirated works and harm the internal market.

Practical effect: a copy of a film downloaded from a pirate site is never a private copy, in any EU country. A copy of a video that you accessed lawfully may be, if the other conditions are met.

How the levy works

Because the directive requires compensation, most countries that allow private copying charge a levy on blank media and devices that can store copies. Typical examples include hard drives, USB sticks, memory cards, set-top boxes with recording and smartphones. The amounts are set nationally; in France, by a dedicated commission under Article L.311-1 and following of the intellectual property code.

The levy does not grant a licence to download anything: it compensates for the copies the law already allows.

How the money moves, in the two largest systems:

Step France Germany
Legal basis Articles L.311-1 and following, CPI Sections 54 and following, UrhG
Who pays The manufacturer or importer of the medium, passed on in the retail price Manufacturers of devices and storage media, with importers and dealers jointly liable
Who sets the amounts An administrative commission (Article L.311-5) decides which media are subject and at what rate Tariffs negotiated or set for each device category
Who collects A collecting body on behalf of authors, performers and producers Collecting societies acting jointly
What you, the buyer, notice A slightly higher price on drives, phones and memory cards The same

The point for a downloader is simple: paying the levy on your phone does not turn an unlawful download into a lawful one. It only finances the copies the exception already permits.

What the exception does not cover

Action Covered by private copy?
Copy of a video accessed lawfully, kept on your own device Possibly, depending on national law
Copy from a pirate or unauthorised source No (ACI Adam)
Breaking DRM or other technical protection No, prohibited by Article 6 of the directive
Sending the copy to friends or colleagues No
Uploading the copy or sharing it on peer-to-peer No
Using the copy in a public screening or business No

Technical protection deserves a closer look: Article 6 requires member states to protect “effective technological measures”. Article 6(4) lets states take measures so that some exceptions can still be exercised, but rights holders may restrict copying of on-demand services under contract. In practice, encrypted streaming services are outside the reach of private copying. Our DRM explainer describes how the encryption works.

Country notes

  • France. Article L.122-5, 2° of the Code de la propriété intellectuelle allows copies strictly reserved for the private use of the copyist, made from a lawful source. Circumventing technical measures is punished by Article L.335-3-1.
  • Germany. Section 53 of the Copyright Act (UrhG) allows private copies, but excludes sources that are obviously unlawfully produced or made available.
  • United Kingdom. The personal-copy exception (section 28B CDPA) introduced on 1 October 2014 was quashed by the High Court in 2015 in R (BASCA) v Secretary of State, because it offered no compensation. The time-shifting exception of section 70 still allows recording a broadcast at home to watch it later.
  • United States. There is no private copy exception; personal copying is assessed under fair use. See is downloading videos legal?.
  • Canada. Section 29.22 of the Copyright Act allows reproduction for private purposes under five cumulative conditions: the source copy is not infringing; it was legally obtained, other than by borrowing or renting; no technological protection measure is circumvented; the reproduction is not given away; and it is used only for private purposes. If you later sell, rent or give away the source copy, the reproductions must be destroyed. Section 29.23 separately allows recording a broadcast to watch later.

Five questions to test your own copy

Answer each question honestly. One “no” is enough to take the copy outside the exception.

  1. Was my access lawful? A purchase, a free broadcast, an authorised stream or a file the rights holder published. Not a pirate site, not a leaked file.
  2. Am I copying for myself only? Not for a class, a team, a client or a public screening.
  3. Did I avoid breaking any protection? No decryption of DRM, no tool that removes encryption keys.
  4. Will the copy stay with me? No sending, uploading, syncing to a shared folder or seeding.
  5. Does my country actually have the exception? France, Germany and most EU states do; the UK and the US do not.

Scenarios at a glance

Scenario Private copy?
Recording a free-to-air TV programme to watch next week Usually yes, and covered by time-shifting rules in the UK and Canada
Ripping a DVD you bought, protected by CSS encryption No in France and Germany, because the protection is circumvented
Saving a film from an illegal streaming site No, the source is unlawful
Copying a lecture your university published openly for you to watch Often unnecessary: check whether a licence already allows it
Keeping a copy of a rented digital film after the rental ends No: in Canada borrowed or rented copies are expressly excluded, and elsewhere DRM usually prevents it

Lawful alternatives that never depend on the exception

If you need copies you can rely on, avoid the grey zone:

Frequently asked questions

Does the private copy exception let me download a film from a streaming site?

Only if the source is lawful, the copy stays strictly private and no technical protection is bypassed. Most commercial streaming services encrypt their video with DRM, and breaking it is prohibited regardless of the private copy exception.

Can I share a private copy with my family?

National laws generally limit the exception to the copyist's private use, sometimes including the family circle for viewing. Sending files to others, posting them online or sharing them on peer-to-peer networks falls outside the exception everywhere.

Why do I pay a levy on my phone or hard drive?

The directive requires fair compensation for rights holders when a country allows private copying. Most member states, including France and Germany, collect it as a levy included in the price of storage media and devices.

Does the UK have a private copy exception?

Not a general one. The personal-copy exception added as section 28B of the CDPA in 2014 was quashed by the High Court in 2015. Time-shifting of broadcasts under section 70 remains.

Does the exception apply to software or games?

No. Computer programs follow a different EU regime with a narrow back-up copy right. This page concerns audiovisual works such as films, series and clips.

Sources and open data

  1. Directive 2001/29/EC, Article 5(2)(b) and Article 6 · EUR-Lex
  2. Judgment in Case C-435/12, ACI Adam and Others, 10 April 2014 · Court of Justice of the European Union
  3. Code de la propriété intellectuelle, Articles L.122-5 and L.311-1 · Légifrance
  4. R (BASCA) v Secretary of State for Business, Innovation and Skills [2015] EWHC 2041 (Admin) · The National Archives (UK)
  5. Copyright, Designs and Patents Act 1988, section 70 (recording for time-shifting) · legislation.gov.uk